• Blog
  • Giveaways
  • Legal/Disclaimers
  • About Me/Contact Me

This is the Motherhood

Media Tests
entertainment•movie

What are Media Tests for bias?

July 18, 2020

What are Media Tests for bias and why is it important in the scope of greater diversity and inclusion in storytelling?

Media Tests

Storytelling on screen starts on the page and when you are looking at issues of diversity and inclusiveness I watch movies through a very focused lens and ask myself: Does it pass any Media Tests? Does it fail any? When watching a film I always check to see if certain standards are met for me in terms of diversity and inclusion. There are various Media Tests that measure these elements. Each of these “tests” serves as a reminder for writers and filmmakers to consider representation standards that reflect people that may not always be in the room.

When breaking down criticism of entertainment it is easy to rely solely on opinion. The problem with that is that all opinions are laced with inherent bias. Denying the existence of an inherent bias not only makes you a lousy critic, it makes you lazy. To fall into the old trope of “well that’s my opinion” ignores and dismisses your readers as well as diminishes the value of their opinion by placing yours above theirs. To some extent, when it comes to criticism that is OK. Because it is done in the effort to present another viewpoint that is outside of the readers own world.

A lot of times when people hear that I am a blogger their first response is asking me if I write about Disney because I live in Orlando, their second is asking me how on earth I make money at it, and the third is wondering what makes my opinion different and why they should read it. The truth: I do write about Disney, I do make money (but not that much) it is more for the love of communication, and the last answer is complicated. I really don’t feel that my opinion is any more valid than other people’s opinion. The best I can do is observe and communicate what I saw and experienced and then follow up with my interpretation of it. Though there may be one more element that I would like to bring to the table that has nothing to do with my opinion and is more of a tool to measure that helps with the idea of breaking down inherit bias in entertainment.

film tests

So what are the Media Tests I look at to try to assess if a film meets the minimum standards for inclusion and diversity?

The top 8 Media Tests that I apply while watching a film or television show:

The Bechdel Test

This test has one piece of criteria and most films fail to pass it- Do two female characters have at least one conversation that’s not about a man?

The Racial Bechdel Test

Same simple rules as The Bechdel Test, applied to people of color- At least two POC must have a conversation that’s not about a white person.

The Mako Mori Test

Three boxes must be checked to pass- 1) At least one female character that 2) gets her own narrative arc and that 3) is not about supporting a man’s story.

The Ellen Willis Test

Does the story make sense if the genders are flipped?

The Tauriel Test

In a given work, at least one woman be good at what she does to pass this test.

The Deggans Rule

This test requires a show that’s not about race to include at least two non-white human characters in the main cast.

The DuVernay Test

A work passes it if “African Americans and other minorities have fully realized lives rather than serve as scenery in white stories.”

The Vito Russo Test

Was created by the organization GLAAD and has three requirements- 1) The film must contain a lesbian, gay, bi, or transgender character 2) that character must not be predominantly defined by their orientation or gender identity- they need to be as unique as straight cis characters and 3) they must be important enough to affect the plot—they can’t just crack some jokes or “paint urban authenticity.”

film camera

There are other Media Tests that gauge things like non-fiction work (The Finkbinder Test) and a test for toys (The Lauredhel Test).

Here is a wonderful link to a site to get you started on learning about those!

Media Tests are not meant to replace opinion or influence reviews past the simple acknowledgment of pass or fail. Not every project necessarily requires a pass or fail when it comes to some of these subjects if they do not serve the story (though one could argue diversity and inclusion always serve the story). Each test is supposed to be a gateway to discussion and thoughtfulness that will hopefully open the door to diversifying the “voices in the room” and on the page, challenging creators to consider new viewpoints when developing and telling stories.

entertainment Media movie

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trackbacks

  1. Should you see “The Personal History Of David Copperfield”?- This is the Motherhood says:
    August 11, 2020 at 2:00 am

    […] Something I look for in every film is to see is whether or not it passes a set of media bias tests. Here is a list of the tests and what the criteria is for each to pass or fail. […]

    Reply
  2. Discussing representation and inclusion with the creators of Pixar’s SOUL - This is the Motherhood says:
    August 27, 2020 at 2:16 pm

    […] I support. Pixar’s Soul has entered the chat! Of course I can enjoy a movie when all of the Media Bias boxes are not checked… but the care, consideration, and CREATIVITY allowed to a film that too the […]

    Reply
  3. “The War With Grandpa”: Fun for the whole family? - This is the Motherhood says:
    October 9, 2020 at 1:25 pm

    […] As media bias is an important issue in my life in the media that I consume and promote, this movie’s feeling of relativity was just that: relative. It wasn’t difficult when watching the movie to see which tests the movie passed and failed in terms of diversity and inclusion, but that being said I learned a big lesson with this film. While watching it I couldn’t get over that they had attracted such a star-studded cast to this project. Later in an interview with the producers of the film (an acutely aware and impressive 15 year old executive producer Tre Peart and his parents Marvin & Rosa Peart) while they were speaking about Robert DeNiro’s involvement in the project and willingness to be involved with future projects I started to remember a tweet that caught my eye last year from Ava DuVernay. […]

    Reply
  4. Disney’s movie Godmothered: A modern day fairy tale worth the watch? says:
    December 6, 2020 at 4:02 am

    […] Every film that I review has one set of criteria that I always take a moment to examine closely outside of whether or not I like the film. Here is a link to the media bias checks that I have listed below in case you want to learn more abou… […]

    Reply
Previous “Mighty Oak” Parent Review
Next Get a Sneak Peek at ‘Marvel’s 616’, Coming to Disney+ September 25th!

Related Posts

mighty oak review

“Mighty Oak” Parent Review

Cars Show

Lightning McQueen Racing Academy… Ready, Set, GO!...

What is #MyMovieChat?

David Copperfield review

Should you see “The Personal History Of David Copperf...

“It was important to the creators to invite peop “It was important to the creators to invite people in who did not just rubberstamp the work they were doing but to go with them on the full journey to create these characters in the world of Pixar’s Soul as authentic and truthful as possible.” #PixarSoul https://www.thisisthemotherhood.com/pixars-soul.html
On voting day, we wear white! Today is the 100th On voting day, we wear white! Today is the 100th anniversary of the 19th Amendment’s ratification. #vote2020 #19thamendment #womenvote #womenvote100 #voteblue2020 #nineteethamendment #votingmatters #100years #centennial
I had a great time attending the opening night fil I had a great time attending the opening night film at this year’s @floridafilmfest and I have had awesome experiences returning to the movies: https://www.thisisthemotherhood.com/david-copperfield.html
“Pride is not the word I’m looking for...”. “Pride is not the word I’m looking for...”. What an amazing 11th bday for my little #Ravenclaw! #hogwarts #happybirthday #sorted #harrypotter
Yesterday my oldest turned 11 and got her owl and Yesterday my oldest turned 11 and got her owl and got sorted! She is a #Ravenclaw! #harrypotter #hagridcake #happeebirthdaeharry
Guess what we’re watching? So cute! #AD #IMAXon Guess what we’re watching? So cute! #AD #IMAXonHULU #Pandas @kristenanniebell #imaxambassador
It has been a minute since I posted here because I It has been a minute since I posted here because I have been in #covid19 survival mode. We are all happy and healthy, but it feels like we are finally emerging from protective shells. We are still locking ourselves down for the most part and recently added a “new to us” pop up pool to our backyard so we can spend more than 5 minutes outside without melting in the #Florida heat! (Thanks to @ctand.co for the fun pool gifts!) How are you all hanging in there?
Copyright © Plum Picker Productions 2021 This is the Motherhood
Theme by SheShoppes